10.09.2007

Bion-eh-c Woman

I've used the "eh" joke before, but then again, they've made this show before, so I figure... whatever. Which is, in fact, sort of the vibe surrounding this remake - whatever.

Now, I'm no slave to the original show - from hazy childhood memories, the whole Bionic Whoever seemed like standard 70s sci-fi schlock. Battlestar Galactica paved the way for improving on the original, but Bionic is stuck in the mud. It's not that we're treading on hallowed ground, it's that we're following in well-trod footsteps, be they bionic or not. NBC threw a lot of money at this update, but not much in the way of innovation or inspiration.

I won't spent much time on the characters or plot, as clearly neither did the creators. Suffice to say that in the pilot, the Woman becomes Bionic. By the second ep, Dr. Burke has shown up and they battle some improbable virus. By the third ep, I've lost interest. Despite all the gee-whiz high tech-ery, theres not much to care about here.

You've seen the training sequences before, you've seen the fight scenes before, you've seen the cast before. The one new element is Michelle Ryan as Jaime Sommers, but she's a miscast at best. A natural Brit, Ryan comes across as halting and hesitant in the role. The overall feel is squirmishly awkward, which isn't what a show built around the ultimate cyberwarrior of the future needs. Alias, a clear model for this series, had its issues, but buying Jennifer Garner as a supersmooth operator/asskicker wasn't one of them.

Reminiscent of a young Ione Skye, this Bionic Woman is sort of like watching the "she gave me a pen" scene from Say Anything... just with guns and hacky wirework where people leap across huge chasms with their legs flailing and backs arched as if they were hanging from, you know, wires. While the harness may keep the characters from falling flat, the show still does. Pass.

4 comments:

Clare said...

I agree completely. The show looks nice, the effects are decent, the acting is ok, but it's nothing we haven't seen before. It's just a totally straightforward superhero/secret agent plot, the problem is that it's 2007 and we've all seen this a dozen times before. Without any creativity or humor in the treatment of the story, and without any subversion of the usual action and genre cliches there's no point in watching. Just one big boring story we've all seen a dozen times already.

Valerie said...

Poor Michelle Ryan, this show will get canceled before the end of the season and she won't even have enough clout to tout tempurpedic beds à la Lindsay Wagner.

McGone said...

You forgot to mention how Katee Sackhoff shows up in every scene and totally owns Ryan. I'm not a Battlestar Galactica watcher, but what I have seen here has convinced me to go back and see what she did on that show too.

Frank Sirmarco said...

Not terrible, but not very good. I'm still giving it a chance so I can see Katee Sackhoff kick some ass.